Join Us Every Thursday While We READ, RECAP, and REVIEW Smutty Books

Season 2

Oct. 30, 2025

Wrapped: Haunting Adeline by H.D. Carlton

Would we recommend Haunting Adeline? Tune in for our first installment of our Wrapped series where we'll let you know if you should indulge or abstain from this book... or our episode. No spoilers allowed (for the most part).

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 23, 2025

Pen Pal by J. T. Geissinger

Join Nicole and Amanda as we recap Pen Pal... or maybe don't join us if you liked the book because we have very big thoughts. But what a wild ride. Happy spooky season!

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 9, 2025

Hooked by Emily McIntire

Our long-awaited recap of Hooked by Emily McIntire is here! Join Nicole and Amanda to see what we thought about this dark fairytale retelling. Spoiler alert... it's pure chaos.

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 25, 2025

Love & Other Killers by Brynne Weaver

Ta-da! We're back with our favorite characters again for a short story following the Ruinous Love trilogy. Tune in as we join Sloane and the others for their annual game.

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 11, 2025

Things We Left Behind by Lucy Score

Plot Tarts are back for the final installment of Lucy Score's Knockemout series.

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 28, 2025

Things We Hide From The Light by Lucy Score

Amanda's swooning, Nicole's side-eyeing and Lucy Score's Things We Hide From The Light is stirring up some serious debate. Lina is everything but Nash... not as much (at least for Nicole). Buckle up for chaos, laughs and some...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 15, 2025

Things We Never Got Over by Lucy Score

Join us as we talk about Things We Never Got Over by Lucy Score. Nicole's obsessed, Amanda's less so. Cue the banter, the swoons and a heated debate over the grumpy guy next door.

Listen to the Episode
July 31, 2025

Deep End by Ali Hazelwood

Dive into a recap and review of Deep End by Ali Hazelwood with the Plot Tarts. While Nicole delicately suns on shore, Amanda will be drowning.

Listen to the Episode
July 10, 2025

Credence by Penelope Douglas

A two hour recording, cut down to an hour and half and, to be honest, Plot Tarts Nicole and Amanda, are still not sure how they feel about it. Join us as we read, recap, and review, the polarizing book Credence, by Penelope D...

Listen to the Episode
June 27, 2025

Caught Up by Navessa Allen

Why can't we all just get along? Join Nicole and Amanda, as they - once again - go round for round on this weeks episode of Plot Tarts. At least they aren't the only ones with big feelings about it.

Listen to the Episode
June 12, 2025

Silver Elite by Dani Francis

Let's face it, aren't we all thinking the same thing, let's talk about it. Join Nicole and Amanda as they recap, and review the ... AI written?... viral book, Silver Elite by Dani Francis.

Listen to the Episode
June 5, 2025

The Ruinous Love Trilogy, Book Three - Scythe & Sparrow by Brynne Wea…

Join Plot Tarts, Nicole and Amanda as they recap and review Brynn Weaver's book, Scythe & Sparrow . The episode where the only people fighting harder for the their life than Amanda, are Fionn and Rose.

Listen to the Episode